This year we have seen two movies. If we go to Dune 3, it will be three.

I loved the first Dune movie (2021), based on Frank Herbert’s 1960s environmental classic, Dune, set on a desert planet where every drop of water must be conserved. Herbert couldn’t find a publisher for the novel: it was first published in 1965 by a company that specialized in auto repair manuals. After Dune won the Hugo Award and the Nebula Award, the publisher Ace picked it up. This brilliant novel is in print and still pertinent.
And then in 2024 the movie Dune 2 was released. Of course we saw it. There is action, there is war, there is still a lot of sand, but it lacks the coherence of Dune 1. I am not a fan of the sequels Frank Herbert wrote to Dune, and this is based on one of them.
Dune 3 will be released in December. A Christmas Day movie? Well…
The Odyssey: Literary Epic
The film of The Odyssey is a visually-engaging mega-adaptation of Homer’s epic poem. It sounded implausible to make a movie of an epic poem, but it was valiantly undertaken by the director and writer Christopher Nolan.
As a longtime Homer fan, I enjoyed this entertaining movie, and thought it might be a Hail Mary pass for dying classics departments. Canny professors may have substituted The Odyssey for the Iliad on the Greek syllabus. And of course it’s a must-read for Classical Literature in Translation.
Fans of the movie well might read (or at least buy) one of the many excellent translations of The Odyssey: I recommend Robert Fagles, Richmond Lattimore, Robert Fitzgerald, Emily Wilson, Daniel Mendelsohn, Allen Mandelbaum, or even the Chapman’s Homer mentioned by Keats in the poem, “On First Looking into Chapman’s Homer.”
And here’s a thought: The Odyssey should appeal to science fiction fans as well as classics fans. There are many disturbing special effects, monsters, storms at sea, witches, men turned into pigs, and a terrifying Trojan horse. It’s cross-genre!
MY ONLY COMPLAINT: I wish there had been an intermission. The movie is three hour long, and by the time you’ve gone to the restroom, or rushed down the halls of the mall to get a coffee, your mate has to explain the important storm at sea you missed, or why Odysseus is all alone now.
But it’s an excellent movie, and it should pick up some awards. I don’t really follow these things, but it is sui generis… I’ve never seen a movie like this.










