Daily Archives: October 21, 2026

Brontë vs. Austen: “Emily” and “Sense and Sensibility”

You know there’s something wrong with the culture when you find a movie on Netflix about Emily Brontë.

The notion horrified me.  But maybe…? I’m desperate for a good movie.

I did not watch the entire 2-minute trailer, but it resembled a Jane Austen film:  twirling, laughing, emaciated sisters, bonnets on and bonnets off, Emily alone with a man….  Good God! 

And you see, there’s this:  Emily would not have been a movie-goer.  She and her sisters were writers from childhood and would have written or directed their own movie if they’d wanted one.  Branwell preferred drink and opium to writing after a certain point, so he might have gone to the movies – on drugs!

If you don’t want to watch Emily, and I definitely don’t, you can see the latest adaptation of Sense and Sensibility. I watched only part of the trailer but noticed the following:  the actresses wear their hair loose, instead of up, and the film has a non-Austen sexualized atmosphere:  sisters confiding in bed, having pillow fights, and then strangely cuddling in bed, getting out of bed to take walks in a ravishing landscape and, in Marianne’s case, meet her beloved, and Elinor barely touching her boyfriend’s hands, an intensely sexualized moment .  It is mostly a bonnets-off movie! I’m all for sex and bonnets off but I want the book more.

“Will there never be an end of Austen and Bronte films?”  asked my soulmate.

“Never.”

I will wait to watch Sense and Sensibility on Netflix.

Toxic Masculinity or Toxic Femininity?

How many times can the phrase “toxic masculinity” be used in a sentence?

I never use this phrase: there is as much “toxic femininity” as “toxic masculinity” in our culture – and you’re kidding yourself if you deny it.

Recently, at a lecture on 19th-century English literature, I heard the phrase “toxic masculinity” several times.  Oddly, an aging male scholar used it. And, because I’m a Doris Lessing fan, and she denied she was a feminist, and because I want nothing to do with feminist quacks, I have lost the feminist ideals that defined me in my youth. I always wonder, What is the context? What is the source? Or when a man uses the phrase “male toxicity,” is it because he is afraid not to kowtow to women?

Look at female politicians. (They don’t mind being looked at.)  Like male politicians, a number of them are hawkish and unreasonable.  In some states, not only have female governors signed bills into law that ascertain everyone and anyone can carry a gun, but they have waived gun permits, and lowered the age for gun ownership. 

And they say that it is preferable for everyone to carry a gun, and that armed teachers will stop school shootings. As soon as women get political power, they copy the men.

And so if we must use the phrase “masculine toxicity,” we must add  “Toxic femininity” too.  Can you imagine a woman using the phrase “toxic femininity?” No, because it is sexist, for both sexes.

“Male dominance” doesn’t quite have the witch-hunting tone of “male toxicity.” In general, I feel more attention should be given to language, because words can trigger violence against both men and women.