The Blossoming of Henry James:  Objets d’art & Self-Sacrifice

A young Henry James

It was just a bad party, a party where Henry James would not have been caught dead.

“It’s fine if you like that kind of thing,” said a friend with an English degree who was working on a Ph.D. In physics   “What’s wrong with being serious?  In my line of work we’re all serious.”

 “That guy told told me not to be uptight!’”

“That’s because you wouldn’t make out with him, babe. Hell, you don’t have to be perky if you read Henry James.”

That should be my slogan: You Don’t Have to Be Perky If You Read Henry James.  It would have saved time and grief  had I tattooed it on my forehead.

My favorite James

As a woman of a certain age, I am no longer expected to be perky.  (Vivacity is a different thing altogether.)  In fact, it is a wonder to people under 30 that I am still upright. And the fact that I ride my bike astonishes everyone.  Two women applauded (kindly, I hope) a few years back when I biked up an easy hill (I’ve ridden hills for decades), women my age claim I’m an inspiration, and still others clearly thank God they will never ride a bike again. 

But people almost expect one to read Henry James after a certain age.  James, who busied himself with objets d’art and Italian countesses and attractive princes at house parties, settled for being a literary god and may or may not have ridden a bike.  N.B. I have no data on this point.

You will have noted that I am a “Henry James-head.” I recently raved about his remarkable short novel, The Spoils of Poynton, a celebration of a collection of rare objets d’art at the center of an inheritance tug-of-war.

 In my teens and twenties I read most of James’s oeuvre, awed by the elegance of his prose and loving this elite world I had never glimpsed.  I found his obsession with objets d’art both fascinating and disturbing.  James is a lyrical materialist whose characters despise undiscerning or uneducated taste.  In a certain milieu of people in James’s books, taste is the only important quality. James certainly knew and understood the sensibilities of the aristocratic materialists.

Collectors of beautiful things permeate the pages of James. Throughout The Spoils of Poynton, Mrs. Gereth treats her protegee, Veda Fletch, as if she were the only other person who has really understood the significance of her beautiful collection of “things.”.  Veda, however, is ambivalent about Mrs. Gereth’s pride and her battle with her son’s future wife for the collection. Veda’s ethics are more tortured even than James’s other self-sacrificing heroines. She is unwilling to sacrifice herself for the sake of Mrs. Gareth’s collection, even though the sacrifice is one she would willingly make under other conditions.

I am especially interested in Henry James’s Golden period, the turn of the 20th century, when  his three masterpieces, The Golden Bowl, The Wings of the Dove, and The Ambassadors,  were published. The first two depict struggles between materialism and appreciation.

I especially love The Wings of the Dove, which I have read and cried over several times. In my late thirties, I intensely identified with the saintly heroine, Milly Theale, a young, beautiful, rich American invalid who is dying of an unidentified disease but confides only in her new English friend, Kate Croy, whom she has met on her travels in England.  Perhaps I identified because I had survived a serious illness, due to the miracle of modern medicine, and such experiences do change one.  But Milly is noble: she tries to conceal her illness even from her devoted traveling companion.

Not everyone, alas, is as noble and loyal as Milly. Her twisted friend Kate is impecunious and scheming: Kate pushes her attractive boyfriend, Merton Densher, a journalist who makes low wages, practically into Milly’s lap.  Milly had met hm in America and been taken with him.   Merton is impatient, because he wants to be with  Kate, and Kate insists that they hide their relationship from Milly. Kate has turned cold and mercenary:  she thinks she can capitalize on the situation for both of them.  When Merton begins to understand what she expects, he is impatient, incredulous. He is Kate’s dupe and has no desire to exploit Milly.

Milly is a total class act – I won’t let you know what she knows and how she behaves when she knows, but I do wish the world were full of bright, generous people like Milly.  Instead, we have a world of manipulative Kate Croys who will stop at nothing to  get their hands on money.

James knows the Kate Croys and the Milly Theales.  He does not condemn Kate altogether: at the beginning she and Densher are walking in a park; they are secretly engaged, but her rich aunt will not countenance her marriage to a poor man.  Kate’s family is poor, and thus she is living with a rich, bossy aunt.  Until Kate meets Milly, she seems perfectly normal but then she becomes so obsessed with Milly’s money that she is metaphorically ready to kill for it. 

James himself is materialistic: he refrains from painting her as a monster, though her ethics are appalling. But the rest of us, who are not quite so taken with Kate, are relieved that classy Milly makes an unexpected escape.

Henry James, like his brother William, was a philosopher in his way.

MORE JAMES COMING SOON! 

Summer Reading: Henry James & Maud Cairnes

It was a gorgeous June day. We take these days when we can get them.  We didn’t exert ourselves, except to make sandwiches in the kitchen, because it was 90 degrees, and all anybody wants is to sit under a tree and indulge in light reading. I almost said “sit in a tree,” but I must admit those days are gone.  Not gone, however, are days when we lounge under a tree and sigh over Henry James’s The Wings of the Dove.

On a recent rereading of The Wings of the Dove, I loved it as much as I did in my twenties.  Back then, I always had a classic going at night, and James, though considered soporific by cynics, seemed to me surprisingly stimulating.  I was absorbed by his magnificent characters, especially the innocent Americans, among them Isabel Archer (The Portrait of a Lady), tricked into marriage by an impecunious Italian prince, and Milly Theale (The Wings of the Dove), a charming, rich, terminally ill young American woman who attracts fortune hunters.

Milly hides her illness even from her companion, Mrs. Stringham, her chaperone in their European travels.  But Milly is manipulated by her clever English friend Kate Croy into confessing she is ill, and then isthrown together with Merton Densher, an English journalist with no prospects. And Milly likes him very much.

To complicate things further, Densher is Kate’s secret fiancé: her rich Aunt Maud will cut her off if she marries a poor man, though Densher would like to marry her on his own income.  Kate’s  scheme is to get her hands on Milly’s money by making her fall in love with Densher.  Densher doesn’t take this too seriously, and  is desperate to spend time with Kate, who becomes colder as the book goes on. Kate’s  hopes for Densher and Milly are  obscene. This is not quite James noir, but in a way it is a novel about a psychological murder.

I’m fascinated by Kate, because in the first section of the novel, she is a kind, ethical woman who offered to stay with her impecunious father and share with him her 100 pounds legacy a year from her mother, while giving the other two hundred to her sister, a poor widow with children. He declined to live with her in poverty and sent her to Aunt Maud, with the hope that she would pass him the odd bit of change (though Maud has forbidden her to see her father). And she is very much in love with Densher at that point.

In a way, Kate’s ruthlessness is the end of Kate. The prospect of money ruins her. And yet I’m not sure James pulls off the transition from Kate the Good into Kate the Cold. She didn’t care about money when she offered to sacrifice herself to her father.

The other novel I’ve read under a tree, or shall I pretend IN a tree, is Maud Cairnes’s Strange Journey, a book in the British Library Women’s Series.  In this charming, comical, very smart little book, Cairnes draws an unforgettable portrait of two women, Polly Wilkinson, the narrator and a housewife, and Lady Elizabeth, who has everything that money can buy and yet has been unhappy since her miscarriage and her husband’s affairs.  Suddenly Polly and Lady Elizabeth  swap bodies, and  have no idea who they are supposed to be.   Have they gone mad?.

How would you feel if you suddenly were translated to another person’s body?  Not only another person, but someone you’d never met and didn’t know?   Suddenly Polly is expected to ride horses, hunt, and exchange witty repartee with sophisticated upper-class folk. And Lady Elizabeth finds herself living in a middle-class home on a budget, responsible for two children and a hard-working husband. 

Later, the two women find out how they became aware of each other. Polly wistfully observed Elizabeth oe night in a Rolls Royce.  She longed to climb in, lean against a soft cushion, and be driven to a pleasant home where everything would be done for her.

And when they try to reconstruct what happened,  Elizabeth also remembers seeing Polly and envying her access to a simpler life. 

Oddly enough, each learns by body-swapping to cope better with her problems by learning the other’s skills.

A charming, lively, light novel which I will read again!